Sunday, December 9, 2007

Define genre

You know, I think now, is a good time for my first rant.

See I have this "friend" who has argued with me about what genre of music a band should be labeled under. Actually, it was more like him just sort of ranting to himself, I was just stuck in the crossfire. He has this "Thing" where he has to classify everything he hears, and to sit there and listen to him and these outlandish branches of music is actually entertaining. Until you try to go through your play list and classify everything. Then your brain begins to bleed.

I'm not going to mention any names here (*cough* begins with a J *cough*), and I'm not going to say I completely disagree with this person (whom has a beard). But it has been sort of bothering me.

The concept of placing bands under certain genres of music is something that we all partake in. I mean, you have to have some sort of idea about what a certain band sounds like before you listen to it. But I do believe that, it can get out of hand. Wtf is grindcore anyways? What makes hardcore different than grindcore? and when does it drift into noizecore or some other gay ass core out there? When Does Death Metal Turn into Black Metal? And what is "Nu-metal", and how is it different than regular metal? what makes Rap Different than Hip-Hop? What is Prog-punk? Noise-rock? Phycobilly? I'm sure there are reasons behind these, but i really don't want to know them (If i did I would go ask my "Necro" Friend [btw wtf is necro?])

Another problem with genre defining is that people often refuse to listen to certain music because it is simply labeled as a certain genre, totally missing out on some great music. I know too many people that just refuse to listen to any hip-hop at all, ever. Hip-hopophobia. It's pretty bad in the Rock community. Too bad, they're missing out on some really good stuff out there. Sure you have to digg through alot of shit, but thats a part of the fun of it, isn't it?

Ill admit, I have and still sometimes do prejudge certain music due to genres. anything with the words "Pop", "Country" and even "Emo", I often find myself avoiding like a plague. I try not too, I pride mtself in my wide range of music, however, I can't really help it. Its gonna take some really good "pop-country-emo" artists to break this, Sorta how like how the Beastie Boys Broke my Hip-hopophobia.

As I was pondering as to whether I like genres or believe they overcomplicated things, I came to a realization. I seemed to be drawn to bands that defy musical genres. Just look at what is probably my favorite band of all time, CKY. What the fuck are they? Well they are definitely Rock. and then what? where do you go from there. Are they metal? Alternative? They really could go either way.

What about my second fav, CONVERGE. They definitely have a history in the hardcore scene, but they also have a obvious metalcore sound to them (wtf, "metalcore"?), and yet when you hear Jacob Bannon's fucking Bark, it immdiatly brings you to extreme and death metal.

Another fine case is DAUGHTERS, who also appears on my favs list, and is actually the reason behind this whole post. After seeing them, I asked my short hairy aformentioned friend what he thought of it, and he went to completely bash the show, then afterwards went on his way to try to classify them. I said "Dude, who gives a fuck what genre they play, Its either good, or its shit." I forget what left feild group he put them in, I personally can't think of any.

So what do you do when you can't put a certain band in a definite genre? In my case, I went out and bought all their shit. After that, I never gave it a real thought until now.....

No comments: